Ok, so I had big plans for this post – really dig up some great research on the process behind this consumer good. But let me be honest, I ran short on time and I think it is important that this subject be mentioned in time for Valentine’s Day. I think the point will remain without all the gory details on strip mining, mountain top removal, lost lives…
When I was young I remember clearly shopping for jewelry with my parents – it was a special trip to Boston for this rare purchase. My mom taught me how to identify well made fine jewelry from lower quality goods – are the edges well constructed? Is the piece hollow or solid? If hollow, is the material strong enough to hold its shape? Are any stones of high quality? And of course I learned the 4 C’s of diamonds.
So is this a solicitation for my Reader-Friends to buy me a bauble for Hearts Day? No, but I know many people do celebrate love with jewelry. So first, let me encourage you to select finely crafted items. Let me also encourage you to think about these things:
- Jewelry is hard on Mother Earth. All gems and stones are mined as are precious metals. The mining process destroys ecosystems and strips land of natural elements, leaving rubble behind.
- Mining is hard on miners. There are, especially in non-industrialized nations, real human rights issues for mine workers. I do not speak to a great knowledge about Blood Diamonds and other extremes of these issues – but to be sure, people are taken for granted in the process of obtaining precious materials for baubles (perhaps one of the least truly necessary purchases possible!).
What is a girl (or guy) who likes sparkly things to do? Here are some options:
- Less is more. As stated, I like well crafted jewelry. This usually costs a little more than poorly made “fine” jewelry and certainly than mass produced items. So stick to the budget and select just one piece for a special occasion rather than just collecting pretty things. Only in the last few years has our budget allowed for adding pieces of jewelry beyond our wedding rings. But each piece has been purchased for something in particular: a baby, a promotion. There is a story and flood of memories when I see these items – they make me feel good because of those strong associations.
- Estate Jewelry. This is a great option if there are stores in your area that sell Estate goods. Yes, this is used jewelry (see also, your local pawn shop). But good quality wears well and it is like a little treasure hunt. I feel confident saying that your budget will go further as well. When I was pregnant with Dante my knuckles grew – and never shrank again. So my wedding rings no longer fit and I didn’t want to resize until we thought we were all done with pregnancy. I didn’t like that I had no wedding ring, though. So I went to see what the cheapest thinnest wedding band cost at our local jeweler. More than I wanted to spend. Then I noticed the vintage and estate case. Like a light bulb over my head. What a great way to save cash and reduce my impact on the world. A nicer ring at half the price.
- Go gem free. There are amazing pieces of shaped and sculpted metals out there that are lovely without gems. Gemstones are removed from the earth in all sorts of ways, as are metals. Reduce impact by just consuming one resource. There are other options as well such as enameled pieces (popular right now). Another option here is lab created gems. Chemically the same as one from the ground but grown as a crystal structure in a lab. Much more affordable as well, but of course not as “precious” as a rare stone.
- Reshape something old. I remember hearing from an uncle that he and his wife were melting down the gold from their wedding rings to make anniversary rings for the 20th. I just thought that was the most romantic thing. But it is also a great was to reduce demand for precious metals.
- Pearls. Farmed pearls (pretty much all that are available today) have less impact on the environment – and actually can only thrive in clean waters. The whole oyster is used for industrial purposes…
- Artisan pieces. Moving away from the “fine jewelry” category and into “fashion jewelry” you can find amazing, creative works of art in paper jewelry, glass jewelry, even recycled rubber (had to have a link on that!).
If you are considering a gift of jewelry – or want to leave this page up to hint to someone else that you would like them to consider a gift of jewelry – think about the impact of these very fun but actually frivolous items. Just like any purchase, there are many ways to make this is a bit more considered and mindful and reduce the resources you are consuming and the impact on the earth. However you show your love, Happy (early) Valentine’s Day!






